Josh Blackman: Sam Alito, Roe v. Wade, and Libertarians
May 4, 2022 | Tags: "Roe V Wade", Abortion, constitution, law, REASON, Supreme Court
The leaked draft of a Supreme Court opinion by Associate Justice Samuel Alito overturning Roe v. Wade (1973) and Planned Parenthood v. Casey (1992) has sent shock waves throughout America, with pro-choice and pro-life advocates scrambling to figure out what happens next if the right to an abortion is withdrawn at the federal level. "Roe was egregiously wrong from the start," wrote Alito in February. "We hold that Roe and Casey must be overruled."
While there's no question whether the document is authentic (Chief Justice John Roberts says it is), many questions remain. First and foremost among them: Does the draft, written up in response to Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization, a case challenging Mississippi's ban on abortions after 15 weeks, represent the current thinking of the Court's majority? We won't know for sure until a ruling is released sometime before the end of June.
What's the best way to think about abortion rights, Roe v. Wade, and Alito's arguments from a libertarian perspective? I spoke with constitutional scholar Josh Blackman, a professor at South Texas College of Law Houston, an adjunct scholar at the Cato Institute, and a blogger at The Volokh Conspiracy. Blackman is an unabashed admirer of Alito's draft, writing that it "meticulously dissects, and forcefully responds to, every conceivable position in favor of retaining Roe and Casey."
I'm not convinced about that at all and, in a wide-ranging conversation about the history of abortion and "fundamental rights," the changing nature of the Supreme Court, federalism, and partisan politics, we go deep on whether returning decisions about abortion to the states will increase or decrease individual liberty. This is an important discussion about a topic that will likely dominate politics for months to come.
Today's sponsors include:
- The Soho Forum, which is hosting a debate in New York City on Monday, May 2 with Reason's Elizabeth Nolan Brown and investigative journalist and activist Julie Bindel about legalizing prostitution and other forms of sex work. The doors open at 6:30 PM at The Sheen Center on 18 Bleecker Street and there's a reception you can attend afterwards; tickets start at just $12 for students. If you can't attend, you can livestream the event for just $6. Get 25 percent of all tickets by using the discount code REASON. Go here for details and to purchase tickets.
- INKL is an innovative app that gives you unlocked access to news from over a 100 trusted global sources, including The Economist, The Atlantic, Bloomberg—and Reason. At INKL, journalists scour through news from around the world and present every important story from multiple perspectives. And on top of that, INKL also highlights positive stories. For $100 a year, INKL gives you access to premium news that would otherwise cost $12,000 in combined subscriptions. Go to this special link and get an additional 25 percent off for being a Reason reader. You can get a whole year's worth of headache-free news for just $75.
The post Josh Blackman: Sam Alito, <i>Roe v. Wade</i>, and Libertarians appeared first on Reason.com.